Sunday, February 8, 2009

Can You Fool Karma?

This question arose directly out of discussions I had with my friend about the nature of karma. His take is that you can't escape karma so accept it and try to accumulate good karma. In other words, do good and good things will happen to you. On the contrary, I've always felt that's too simplistic an idea and karma is definitely subtler than that. Since the topic was vague enough to be pondered upon, I decided to devote some time writing about it.

In broad terms, karma can be defined as: every action has an equal reaction, perhaps not necessarily opposite. Or, any action you take will generate its own associated karma. However, good and bad are at best pretty subjective concepts. They depend largely upon context. Change the context, and the good karma that you were happily accumulating, might just turn into something else. Which is where the subtlety of karma kicks in. Every action will have a reaction, and it will find its way back to you. It doesn't have to be black-or-white good and bad. It'll usually be a grey mixture of both, just like any action you take.

While pondering over this, I was struck by a sudden idea : what if you could figure out how to outwit karma? What if you managed to figure out what actions to take to get a certain result? Wouldn't that actually be a simplified form of karma at work? People do it all the time without consciously thinking about it as such. Want good grades? Study harder. Simple karma at work.Except that there are no guarantees in life. The consequences of your actions might be completely different from what you expected. Probably because trying to base your actions on their possible karmic outcome is like trying to play chess against...say, God? No matter how far ahead you calculate, you can never be sure of the outcome, which, annoyingly enough, karma has already calculated. Karma is subtle, and it'll always win. You might calculate for 5 years ahead and then find that 10 years in the future karma outwits you. Or that you lost 5 years running after something you never really wanted at the end of it.What if you spend all your time calculating future outcomes in an effort to beat karma. Through inaction, you would try to accumulate as little karma as possible by acting as little as possible and only when you're pretty sure of the outcome. Well, karma wins again. You wouldn't have much of a life right? Karma at work again, no matter how subtly, simply because even inaction would come with its own karma…

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

umm...i think ur misinterpreting karma....it is not something v battle against...."or try to fool"...it is just a tool to achieve a desired result....it helps us in changing our fate....
Sri Krishna says to Arjuna, 'Your only duty is to act (right to work) and not to hanker after the fruits (or the results) thereof.' (Gita Chapter II: 47) Be not the purpose of your actions. Let not the work bind and blind you.
hence, karma dictates do wat is perceived white, and if it is black for someone else...u leave it on their shoulders d power to decide whether ur deeds are right or not.....u reduce that shade of gray...its never enough to just do the right thing....if it is not understood as right.....it wont b considered as "RIGHT".
v can never forget that d final decision is not ours.....and that fact can differentiate something from being good for one to being good for several...so like above...do...and if its good enough...reap..

Anonymous said...

al in al....only ones actions decide ones destiny....(big words)...inaction reaps inaction...action reaps action....good for good...bad for bad...no guarantees true....but its just a chance ur taking...whether its worth it...u decide..u gta agree....inaction wont ever lead to action now wud it???cant just sit and expect the pen to move on its own now...all our deeds do is give us chance...rest all is upto....um...fate(hate that word)...

Kapila Pande said...

@anuj
im sorry your comments are way too long for me to read...i have read the gita and your discourse is probably punctuated with oodles of philosophy and as much as i admire your love for the subject i am in no mood to dispute this post - it was just an opinion you are more thn welcome to dispute it

Blog Archive